Folders

Folders are one of the simpler taxonomies. We’ve gotten very used to the idea over many years of storing files on our computers. Every computer uses the same system with almost no variation.

Folders can contain other folders. They form a tree structure. A single item (often a file) can exist in only one folder.

There are extensions to this concept, symlinks for example, but the essential structure is that one item exists in only one folder.

Strengths

The great advantage of folders is their unlimited depths. No matter how many things I have to store, because folders can be inside other folders, I can create a huge tree containing an unlimited number of items.

Folders are also extremely widely understood. Most people who have used a computing device of some sort, have used folders. This results in an extremely shallow learning curve. Use the word folder, and people immediately know what to do with them.

Drawbacks

It can be hard to find stuff in folders. Did I put that thing inside my work folder, or my projects folder? Where did I create that folder?

Navigating folders can also be cumbersome. It’s necessary to go into each folder to see what’s inside it. This can make searching time consuming, opening many folders to see what’s inside them.

Folder names can also be confusing. Often the folder itself can have a short name “Pictures” which only makes sense in context. For example, a folder like “Work > unchaos > Resources > Media > Pictures” tells me what I can expect to find there, but just “Pictures” alone, doesn’t give me enough information to know what is inside.

Care to share your thoughts on folders? Do you have ideas about how to improve on folders? Please share in the comments…

Many tools

I use a lot of awesome tools to store my data. I have some “stuff” in trello, evernote, google keep, todoist, my email, text files, and probably other places I’m forgetting. Each of these tools is great in its own way. Similarly, they also all feel limited in their ability to organise.

In trello I have lists inside boards and labels, 1>1×1. Evernote has notebooks and tags, 1×1. Google keep has colours and labels, 1×1. Todoist has hierarchical projects and labels, n>1×1.

Structure

These all share the same essential structure. There are multi level folders, sometimes limited to 1 or 2 levels, and there are single level tags. Usually an item can exist in only one folder, and in many tags.

For example, in todoist, a task lives in a single project, but that project can be inside another project. In trello a card can exist in only one list, that list inside only one board.

Somehow I want more flexibility than these limitations will allow.

Type

One limitation that all of these platforms share is type. In all of these platforms, there is 1 single type.

There are sometimes different variations on these types. For example, google keep has lists or notes. Trello supports all kinds of stuff inside their cards, lists, attachments, dates, and more.

Fundamentally though, there is no option for me to describe what something “is”. If I create a card that represents a person in Trello, there is no way for me to say “this is a person”. There are workarounds, but all with their limitations.

Ideas?

How could these tools be improved? What would a better tool offer? Is there a killer feature in this mix that you’ve been waiting for someone to build? We’d love to hear your feedback in the comments…